The Rating System

Written by Maggie & Mike on September 10th, 2008

Our ratings may seem to follow a relatively uniform pattern, but it’s because we have very specific evaluation criteria! Here are the details of the rating system that we use, for handy future reference!

1 StarUnwatchable in all respects, lacking even unintentional comedy.

2 StarsAwful, but you could watch it once.

3 StarsMediocre, but has its moments.  Probably the lower limit for reevaluation.

4 StarsFatally Flawed; an otherwise average film with flaws that can’t be overlooked.

5 StarsAverage in every way. Films that provoke ambivalence.

6 StarsMemorable, has moments of excellence that outshine weaknesses.

7 StarsRecommended! This film excels in some respect & has good replayability.

8 StarsHighly Recommended! Well-executed & thought-provoking, an important film.

9 StarsClassic (or Likely Future Classic), nigh-faultless & could potentially be considered…

10 StarsPerfectThe best of the best!

Leave a Comment